I’m daily investigating teaching tools in the hope of finding one that gives me the dopamine hit I get from discovering a really great one. Every once in a while, something comes onto my radar that immediately stimulates my brain’s reward and pleasure centres. That’s what eduCanon did.
Like most great ideas, eduCanon is based around a really simple concept; it really only does one thing – but it does that one thing very well. It allows you to embed questions into any screencast (or any video for that matter) hosted on YouTube, Vimeo or TeacherTube, and it tracks your student’s responses to them.
As students watch the video (from within eduCanon), and the playhead reaches the time marker at which you’ve inserted a question, the video automatically pauses, and the question slides in from the left. Once the student has read and answered the question, she clicks “Submit”. Then your explanation appears, either explaining why the response they chose was incorrect, or confirming that it was correct. On clicking the “Continue” button, the video automatically resumes playing until the next question is reached. It’s really quite a fantastic thing to add to your video lessons, helping students to stay focussed and leaning forward while watching.
Because eduCanon uses HTML5, rather than Flash, playback works great on an iPad, too.
The first time students watch a video, they are unable to skip through the video; they have to watch the whole thing from start to finish and attempt every question. Once they have watched it once, however, they are then able to come back at a later date and skip around the video reviewing specific parts. This is useful if (say) they understand the introductory concepts in a video, but want to review more sophisticated concepts toward the end.
The process of building questions into your video is utterly friction-free (that’s one of the things that impressed me most about it). You paste in the URL of the video, then watch it play. When it gets to a point at which you want to ask a question, you simply click the “Build Question” button. Then you type in the question, two or more (multiple choice) answers, click the radio button beside the correct answer, type in an explanation for each of the multiple responses, and click the “Save Question” button. Simple!
You have the option of publishing your videos as “public” which means you can share them with anyone to use for personal learning/revision. If you would like to see it in action, have a look at this sample which I have published as a public video. The answers people choose in a public video are not collected by eduCanon.
The real magic happens though, when students link to you (using your teacher code). You can assign a video to the class, and then eduCanon collects data for you on your class’ completion of the task and their responses to your questions.
One of the most commonly asked questions I receive about flipped and blended learning is “How can you know if your students have watched the video?”. Well, this is one way to know!
I think it’s remarkable that all of those features are 100% free! (and that includes add-free). An optional “premium” subscription ($48/year) gives you additional features, such as the ability to export your class data as a .csv file so you can import it into your own class record-keeping software or Excel spreadsheet. A premium subscription also gives you the ability to create free response questions (whereas the free version only allows multiple choice questions).
Verdict: This is the most exciting new web 2.0 platform I’ve found this year so far. I’d recommend it for anyone who makes screencasts or educational videos for their class. The small investment of time required to type in the questions should see a big payoff in student engagement.
Nice review Douchy and a great product. Making it easier and easier to flip/blend the classroom. I tried a similar product called EdPuzzle which was also very easy to use, you should also check that out
Thanks Justin – I’ll give it a look! Cheers 🙂
Reblogged this on MUFY Professional Learning.
I know eduCanon is the leader in this space, but Zaption is also a very cool product!
I don’t know if they are the leaders in this space, but they are copying all the features from EDpuzzle (cropping, voice, open ended questions, student project…)
I’ve played with EDpuzzle and I quite like that too. It is very similar and in many ways it is better (but not in every way). Obviously a lot comes down to opinion – but for what it’s worth here is mine:
• COST: Both are free (compared to Zaption) which is great. (edPuzzle is *more* free – as there are no premium accounts and it gives you some features that you need to pay for a premium eduCanon account for.) WINNER EDpuzzle.
• FORMAT: YouTube videos in eduCanon play in HTML5 irrespective of the platform. In EDpuzzle they play in HTML5 on an iPad and Flash on a computer. I prefer EDpuzzle in this respect because videos with closed captions on YouTube don’t work in HTML5. WINNER EDpuzzle
• FEATURES: EDpuzzle does more. It’s more flexible. You can add open-ended questions and even just comments as well as multiple choice questions. In eduCanon, you can only add multiple choice questions with a free account. WINNER: EDpuzzle.
• VIDEO MANIPULATION: Both platforms let you crop the youtube video (so your students only have to watch the relevant part). One thing EDpuzzle allows you to do is dub your own audio over a video if you don’t like the sound of the narrator’s voice! WINNER: EDpuzzle.
• INTERFACE: This is where eduCanon streaks ahead. EDpuzzle isn’t really hard to navigate your way around, and the built-in tutorials are fairly helpful. But it just “feels” fiddly and awkward to use in a hard-to-put-my-finger-on kind of way. I found myself having to watch the “show me how” tutorials at each step, and even then it was often a bit hard to figure out what to click on. Now I’m not a klutz around computers, and I think I’m a pretty good barometer of what typical teachers will be attracted to. And in that department, eduCanon is attractive where EDpuzzle is not so much. When I first opened eduCanon, I didn’t even need to look at tutorials or read ‘how-tos’ – it was obvious what to do. It does less. There are fewer options and it is less flexible. All true. But sometimes less is more. As I said in the post, it only does one thing – but it does that one thing very well. Because of that, I feel attracted to eduCanon in a way that I don’t to EDpuzzle. And in my opinion (and that is all it is) that is it’s real power. If I find it attractive – I think other teachers will too.
For the more technical-minded teachers among us, I think EDpuzzle might be the better choice. It certainly has more features. But for the average teacher – eduCanon is what I’ll show them first. It’s prettier, and just oh-so simple to use.
Zaption does look good – but it’s not free – costing ~$45 for a single basic license. That wouldn’t bother me too much, but for many teachers it would be a deal-breaker.
Agree. Zaption is too expensive. Educanon costs 48$ if you want to embed open questions or collaborate with other teachers. EDpuzzle is 100% free and offers the possibility to upload your own videos. Thanks for the awesome blog!
Thanks for the educanon/edpuzzle comparison. Very helpful as I have been looking at both. So far, I have only tried edpuzzle but I will be trying educanon soon.
You’re welcome. Once you’ve tried it, it would be good to see if your impressions are similar or different.
Pingback: Using Video to teach efficiently | The Possibility Post
Andrew- thanks for taking the time to compare products. Just wanted to let you know that Zaption Basic is now free! (and you can login with edmodo!). Would love for you to check it out again and share your thoughts. Email me if you would like a longer trial of Zaption Pro!
Pingback: Flipped Music Video Lessons On Any Device, Super-Fast | Midnight Music
Pingback: Add Assessment to Video Using eduCanon
Pingback: Make screencasts interactive with eduCanon | Beth's Blog